The mega infrastructure challenge, value Rs.81,000 crore, proposed for the delicate Nice Nicobar Island, has India’s main primatologists involved: the destiny of the endemic Nicobar long-tailed macaque, discovered nowhere else on the planet however within the three Nicobar islands, hangs within the stability.
A press launch from the Affiliation of Indian Primatologists (AIP), says that no wildlife conservation plan (WCP)—not even the one described within the compliance report submitted to the setting ministry by the challenge proponent ANIIDCO (the Andaman and Nicobar Islands Built-in Improvement Company Restricted)—“is able to mitigating the large-scale deforestation and land use alterations purported by the challenge.”
The infrastructure challenge proposed for the Nice Nicobar Island, which features a transshipment terminal, a greenfield township, and an airport, amongst a number of different tasks, entails the felling of over 1,000,000 bushes. This might irreversibly influence the habitat of the Nicobar long-tailed macaque, the primatologists concern.
The AIP has raised a number of considerations about the way forward for this distinctive macaque: a talented forager that subsists on a food regimen of bugs, fruits, and flowers. “The proposed challenge will immediately influence about 27 teams and expose the remaining to extreme vulnerabilities”, says the press assertion.
Additionally Learn | Nice Nicobar: Catastrophe within the making
The compliance report submitted in November 2022 to the setting ministry by ANIIDCO, states {that a} conservation and administration plan has been ready for the Nicobar long-tailed macaque, the robber crab and different endemic species, by the analysis institute SACON (Salim Ali Centre for Ornithology and Pure Historical past, Coimbatore) for a interval of 30 years.The report provides {that a} cumulative allocation of Rs.230.77 crore has been granted to SACON..
Ravaged by the tsunami, sickened by illness
On November 21, 2024, a gathering of the challenge’s monitoring committees was held; right here it was declared that SACON will obtain Rs.59.49 crore over 30 yearssolely for the conservation of macaques; Rs.12.66 crore has been sanctioned for the primary 5 years, and SACON has sought two years to organize a WCP.
The already beleaguered macaque battles a slew of threats and the NITI Aayog–piloted infrastructure challenge is just about to compound a number of present vulnerabilities by “alarming folds”, warns the AIP assertion: The macaque has struggled with habitat loss for the reason that Nineteen Seventies with the inflow of mainland settlers; had been ravaged by the 2004 tsunami; their vary has been severely restricted; have suffered by warmth waves and dry spells, and are susceptible to illness dangers from publicity to home and livestock.
“A novel facet of the macaque is its incapability to tolerate temperatures of as much as 35 °C… With the massive bushes to be felled as per the proposed plan… the breach of this physiological thermal restrict of those macaques is inconceivable to mitigate by a conservation and administration plan,” AIP instructed Frontline.
Furthermore, the large deforestation entailed within the challenge will amplify the continued local weather change-induced decline in precipitation within the island, which can diminish pure meals sources for the macaques. “This may immediate a higher dependence on cultivars and anthropogenic sources”, and this, says the press launch, might “exacerbat[e] present hostilities with individuals similar to poisoning, injuring, [and] taking pictures.”
“A challenge of such an enormous scale would have been scrapped on the ideation/session section if biodiversity and the performance of the island ecosystem had been valued”
The Nicobar long-tailed macaque additionally occurs to be “a remarkably understudied species”, and “it’s inconceivable to assemble crucial information to tell its conservation and administration in a brief span of two years, the time sought by SACON to organize a WCP”, states the press word.
For example, we nonetheless don’t absolutely know: Their possible inhabitants decline in coastal areas; their genetic construction and vulnerability to illnesses; the ecological, behavioural, and sociocultural heterogeneities amongst macaque teams; the immunology and parasitic load of macaques and their susceptibility to brokers alien to the island.
“With out complete long-term analysis on the distinctive options of the Nicobar long-tailed macaque on an island that’s equally distinctive, and in absence of a ‘proof of idea’, a WCP dangers straying from objectivity and practicality, decreasing it to a hole procedural train”, the press word cautions.
A land use change of such an enormous scale “is not going to solely push the species in the direction of useful extinction (i.e., the place the macaque’s contributions to the ecosystem are misplaced) but additionally threaten floral and faunal species which can be ecologically linked with it”.
Additionally Learn | An obit for Patai Takaru
The primatologists provide examples of the influence of large-scale deforestation on island-dwelling long-tailed macaques in Simeulue Island, Indonesia and Borneo. “Within the former case, inhabitants dimension is estimated to have declined by 99.5% in 40 years (retaliatory killing is an extra motive)“.
The disbursement of funds to SACON, the Wildlife Institute of India and the Zoological Survey of India (ZSI), to organize a slew of conservation plans for numerous species and ecosystems, demonstrates that “The challenge proponents are detached towards the delicate ecosystems of the island, and haven’t prioritised its distinctive biodiversity of their choices”, AIP instructed Frontline.
“They’ve, as a substitute, handled biodiversity as a hindrance and as an afterthought to merely fulfil procedural and authorized necessities. A challenge of such an enormous scale would have been scrapped on the ideation/session section if biodiversity and the performance of the island ecosystem had been valued”, the related added. ZSI, as an example, has, confoundingly, ready a plan to “translocate” 16,000 colonies of corals.
The leatherback turtle, with its distinctive leathery shell, the world’s largest sea turtle species, which migrates throughout each the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, nests right here. Photograph for illustration
| Photograph Credit score:
Getty Photographs
The mangroves, rainforests, and coasts of the Nicobar are residence to a number of distinctive, and threatened species, lots of that are endemic. These embody the Nicobar megapode, a flightless fowl that builds its nests on the bottom with mud and leaves, and the leatherback turtle, with its distinctive leathery shell, the world’s largest sea turtle species, which migrates throughout each the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, nests right here.
Pankaj Sekhsaria, who has written extensively on the setting, growth, and wildlife conservation, with a particular deal with the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, instructed Frontline: “This assertion by the AIP is a crucial one from a collective of scientists and consultants. That is as specific a priority as there may be to the multi-dimensional catastrophe this challenge goes to ivolve. We are going to do properly to heed their considerations earlier than it’s too late”.
AIP asks in its press launch: “What good is a WCP when, as a substitute of informing insurance policies, it’s obligated to scrub up its mess?” As biodiversity conservation doesn’t function unbiased of different challenge choices, “the larger query is, what’s the weightage given to biodiversity whereas planning and executing mega-scale tasks”?
