Karnataka’s Electrical Bike Taxi Scheme, launched in 2021 with a cheerful promise of fresh, inexperienced, last-mile mobility, has now been quietly towed off the street. What began as an earnest try to spice up eco-friendly transport quickly obtained misplaced in a maze of regulatory loopholes, enforcement lapses, and the type of turf wars that solely Indian city transport can actually ship. By March 2024, the federal government had pulled the spark-plug, citing a veritable buffet of causes—from misuse of white-board petrol bikes masquerading as electrical taxis to security issues and a disinterested response from ride-hailing aggregators. What was purported to be a mild electrical hum of progress become a clunky petrol-fuelled mess, full with unlawful rides, grumbling unions, and agitated regulators.
As an alternative of a fleet of zippy, whisper-quiet e-bikes fixing the age-old drawback of the way to get from the metro station to your entrance door (with out moving into an open manhole), Karnataka discovered itself wrangling with a special beast solely. Non-public white-boarded bikes—usually petrol-run and clearly violating the Motor Autos Act—flooded the streets, many working underneath the bike taxi umbrella and not using a shred of authorized cowl. Confrontations between these riders and conventional auto-rickshaw drivers began cropping up, typically leading to literal avenue battles for territory. Girls’s security was flagged as a serious concern, although one would possibly argue that being on an open two-wheeler is usually much less claustrophobic—and subsequently safer—than being shut inside a rattling, rusting auto with a grumpy driver refusing to take a U-turn.
Then there was the matter of aggregator curiosity—or the dearth of it. Just one firm even bothered making use of for a license, and so they too gave up halfway, like a scholar abandoning their thesis midway via Chapter One. So, the federal government—underneath siege from politically influential auto-rickshaw and cab unions—wielded its favorite software: the blanket ban. By no means thoughts that this successfully flattened not simply unlawful petrol bike taxis however the very electrical future the coverage was designed to usher in.
As of April 2025, Karnataka is caught in what can solely be described as a coverage pothole—one it appears unable or unwilling to pave over. On the one hand, there’s a clear and current want for reasonably priced, versatile, last-mile mobility choices. On the opposite, there’s pink tape, regulatory confusion, and the formidable wrath of the auto unions. For the common commuter—these 1000’s who as soon as, albeit briefly, relied on bike taxis to get to work, Metro, Bus-stand, faculty, or dwelling—the abrupt rollback has been greater than inconvenient; it’s been outright exasperating. You possibly can’t ban an answer with out providing another, however that has by no means been the working logic of the Authorities.
It’s not like Karnataka couldn’t have appeared round and borrowed a web page or two from different Indian states. Goa has had its “Pilots” for many years—bike taxis with yellow quantity plates and riders in uniform, zooming round slim bylanes and ferrying locals and vacationers alike. Cities within the Northeast—Shillong and Aizawl, as an example—have tailored bike taxis brilliantly, utilizing them to navigate hilly terrain and thread via tight city clusters. And but, in Bengaluru, a metropolis that usually markets itself as India’s tech capital, your complete scheme was jettisoned as an alternative of being fastened. As an alternative of placing safeguards in place—obligatory identification, security vests, GPS monitoring, or just yellow boards—the federal government selected to throw the infant, the bathwater, and the bathtub out of the window.
The oft-repeated justification that white-board bikes violate the Motor Autos Act sounds slightly hole when seen in context. Moscow, in the course of the Soviet period, functioned with a pleasant chaos of Ladas doubling up as casual taxis, and no person appeared the more serious for it. Right here in India, when lower-income people discover an sincere method to earn a dwelling—particularly in an space the place the state has failed to offer primary infrastructure—it’s not simply shortsighted however nearly comical to close them down on a technicality. Notably when these very persons are plugging gaps in last-mile connectivity and creating self-employment the place none existed.
In the meantime, Bengaluru’s public transport continues to limp alongside. The metro, now protecting about 77 kilometres throughout town, reaches solely round 23% of residents inside strolling distance and spans lower than 6% of town’s complete space. Growth plans look good on paper and shiny brochures, however commuters don’t journey by PowerPoint. They want choices that work in the present day. BMTC, town’s bus lifeline, is overstretched, underfunded, and in lots of areas, just about absent. Buses are both overcrowded or mysteriously lacking, and in new layouts and outer zones, they continue to be as uncommon as punctual contractors.
On this mess, bike taxis had been a godsend—fast, low cost, and agile, particularly in Bengaluru’s famously apocalyptic site visitors. They may weave via potholes, sneak round gridlocks, and provide aid to individuals who in any other case need to stroll kilometres from a metro cease or negotiate with autos who’d slightly not ply quick distances. But, as an alternative of tightening guidelines and enhancing enforcement, the federal government merely banned the entire thing.
So as to add a remaining be aware of irony, the state had as soon as promised its very personal ride-hailing app to counteract the excessive fee charges charged by personal platforms like Ola and Uber. However very similar to most authorities tech tasks, it’s been “in improvement” for over a 12 months, caught someplace between committee conferences and coding confusion. Within the meantime, aggregators like Rapido insist they’re working in a authorized gray zone, the federal government insists they’re not, and customers are left scratching their heads, uncertain whether or not their subsequent journey will present up—or be impounded.
In March 2025, personal transport unions as soon as once more marched as much as the federal government’s doorstep demanding a complete ban on bike taxis and a discount in street taxes to stop autos from being registered in neighbouring states. And so, the sport of push and pull continues, with the precise commuter caught within the center.
But, let’s be clear: whereas bike taxi operators have a good case, they have to additionally toe the road—at the least the wise components of the legislation that everybody else follows. Taking part in by the principles isn’t nearly legality, it’s about long-term credibility. If they honestly wish to embed themselves into India’s city transport matrix, they should present they’re accountable stakeholders, not simply rogue riders on rented wheels.
Reality be advised, Karnataka’s experiment with electrical bike taxis wasn’t a complete failure—it was a missed alternative. It confirmed that persons are hungry for options, for choices which can be cleaner, faster, and extra reasonably priced. However till insurance policies can preserve tempo with innovation—and till the federal government learns to control with a scalpel slightly than a sledgehammer—the street to progress will stay riddled with pace bumps. And that, expensive reader, is a pity.
Disclaimer
Views expressed above are the writer’s personal.
END OF ARTICLE
